07.10.2026

The Supreme Court clarifies that the sale of a property following an insured event does not, in and of itself, reduce compensation for loss of rent. The damage must be assessed based on the insured interest as of the time immediately prior to the insured event and the coverage agreed upon in the policy.

By Albors Galiano Portales

Supreme Court Decision (Civil Chamber) No. 1411/2026, dated September 10, 2026, addresses the determination of compensable damages in insurance policies that include coverage for loss of rent when, following the occurrence of the loss, the insured transfers ownership of the affected property before the end of the maximum coverage period provided for in the policy.

The dispute stems from a fire at a leased industrial building, which was destroyed as a result of the fire. The property was insured under a comprehensive insurance policy that included, among its supplementary coverages, compensation for loss of rent for a maximum period of twelve months.  Following the fire, the tenant notified the landlord that the lease had been terminated due to the destruction of the warehouse, and months later, the landlord sold the land—along with the remains of the building—to that same tenant.

The insurance company held that the compensation should be limited to the period between the fire and the subsequent sale of the property, on the grounds that, once ownership had been transferred, the insured could no longer suffer an actual loss of rental income. This position was upheld by the Provincial Court of Madrid, which held that any compensation for the period following the sale would amount to compensating for an expectation of profit without any real basis.

The Supreme Court overturns this approach and notes that, pursuant to Article 26 of the Insurance Contracts Act (LCS), damages must be determined based on the value of the insured interest immediately prior to the occurrence of the loss. The Court emphasizes that the insured interest constitutes the economic relationship between the insured and the property exposed to risk, and that damage to that property as a result of the loss is precisely the basis for compensation.

The central issue of the ruling, therefore, lies in determining whether the subsequent transfer of the property can alter the extent of damage that had already occurred. On this point, the High Court considers the causal link between the fire, the termination of the lease, and the resulting loss of rent to be decisive.

In this regard, the Court notes that it was the destruction of the warehouse as a result of the fire—and not its subsequent sale—that led to the termination of the lease agreement. It also emphasizes that the subject matter of the lease, namely the industrial warehouse, was distinct from the subject matter of the subsequent sale, which concerned the land containing the remains of the damaged building.

Based on this reasoning, the Supreme Court concludes that the compensable loss was determined immediately prior to the accident, and that subsequent changes in ownership of the property cannot reduce the coverage initially agreed upon. Consequently, it recognizes the insured’s right to receive compensation corresponding to the full twelve months provided for in the policy, along with the interest established in Article 20 of the Insurance Act (LCS).

The ruling is particularly significant for the interpretation of loss-of-rent coverage in property damage insurance contracts. The Supreme Court reaffirms that the assessment of damages must be based on the insured interest and the circumstances existing at the time of the loss, and that subsequent actions taken by the insured cannot, on their own, be used to limit the compensation.

This doctrine helps define the scope of insurers’ obligations and provides an important criterion for resolving disputes regarding loss of income. In particular, it highlights the importance of distinguishing between the actual cause of the damage and subsequent financial circumstances, without prejudice to the conditions and limitations expressly set forth in each policy.